Happy New Year everyone. As I start my first conference of the year, I begin to wonder what this year’s conference circuit will hold in store and what new and exciting things I’ll learn. One thing I hope is that I’ll see more of a ‘bottoms up’ philosophy appearing in workshops and conferences.
Let me explain, I go to a lot of conferences every year and see a lot of talks given by very dedicated, passionate and clearly experienced teachers. Being both a teacher trainer and a bit of techie I tend to go to those sorts of sessions. Towards the end of last year I was getting a bit fed up. Borrowing some terminology, sessions seemed to be taking a bit of a ‘top down approach’ to teaching and I started to wonder if we were beginning to lose ourselves in the assumption that everyone understood when we said things like Web 2.0 and ‘use a dogme approach’
“Top-down reading models suggest that processing of a text begins in the mind of the readers with
• meaning-driven processes, or
• an assumption about the meaning of a text.”
http://www.sil.org/lingualinks/literacy/ReferenceMaterials/glossaryofliteracyterms/WhatIsATopDownReadingModel.htm
Change ‘reading’ to two of the current topics du jour in EFL – technology and dogme and you may start to get my drift.
Now before the dogmatists start to get their heckles raised, I am not about to have a go. Contrary to popular belief, I have nothing against dogme bar the unnecessary hype. I actually think that as a teacher I put into practice many of the principles that dogmatists hold so dearly. For a while people seemed to divide into two camps, those for technology use and those for dogme. Thankfully that divide seems to be disappearing but, in my opinion, what both sides are still culpable of is a tendency to assume everyone in the world is completely comfortable with both, well that and a lot of hyping. As a result, conference sessions can end up simply saying things like ‘this is a great website’, ‘dogme’ – taking the ‘top down approach’, assuming the audience will leave convinced and able to assimilate and blindly follow what they have just been told.
I think this is exacerbated to some extent by social media networks, quoting Andrew Keen, p.16 The Cult of the Amateur
“The Web 2.0 revolution has peddled the promise of bringing more truth to more people – more depth of information, more global perspective, more unbiased opinion from dispassionate observers. But this is all a smokescreen. What Web 2.0 revolution is really delivering is superficial observations of the world around us rather than deep analysis , shrill opinion rather than considered judgment. The information business is being transformed by the Internet into the sheer noise of a hundred million bloggers all simultaneously talking about themselves.”
Thankfully as 2011 wore on some of the voices started to move more into the bottom up approach.
“A bottom-up reading model is a reading model that
emphasizes the written or printed text
says reading is driven by a process that results in meaning (or, in other words, reading is driven by text), and
proceeds from part to whole.”
http://www.sil.org/lingualinks/literacy/ReferenceMaterials/glossaryofliteracyterms/WhatIsABottomUpReadingModel.htm
Applying this to technology use, I hope that I’ll see sessions that give solid reasons for advocating tech use along with practical ideas that help a teacher integrate it into their teaching if they so wish. Stop overwhelming with the amount of sites and show one or two and lots of ideas with concrete reasons for using them that way we can more people using technology productively. Likewise with dogme, let’s have more of the how to do it rather than the ‘just do it’ approach. Show people how they can do it, don’t just tweet or announce in a session that dogme is the answer. It really isn’t that easy for a teacher to go against the doctrines of their school even if dogme is better than slavishly following a course book. So the more we show how, the sooner dogme will become more mainstream.
Please don’t get the wrong idea I am really not having a go about any sessions, just musing on what I’d like to see more of and on that note,
See you on the circuit and until then ‘bottoms up’








